Smart City Informatics and Urban Food Environments: A Critical Review of Approaches to Mitigating Commercial Determinants of Poor Nutrition
Mark Donald Omong *
University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Illinois, USA.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Poor diet is among the leading modifiable causes of non-communicable disease, and the urban food environment through which commercial actors supply, price, place and promote food is increasingly recognised as a principal pathway linking commercial practices to population nutrition. At the same time, cities are adopting smart city informatics, the integrated use of geospatial, sensor, mobility, transaction, platform and artificial intelligence data to monitor and govern urban systems. Whether these informatics can help mitigate the commercial determinants of poor nutrition, rather than simply describing or even amplifying them, has not been critically examined. This critical narrative review appraises peer-reviewed and institutional literature published between January 2010 and September 2026, identified through structured searching of biomedical and multidisciplinary indexes, citation chasing and institutional sources. Evidence was organised around four questions: how informatics conceptualise and measure urban food environments, what such measurement can and cannot reveal about diet and health, which informatics-enabled approaches have been used to regulate commercial practices, and what governance conditions shape their legitimacy and equity. The synthesis indicates that informatics have substantially improved the scale, temporal resolution and spatial specificity of food environment measurement, particularly through mobility traces, street-level imagery, online food delivery platform data and automated detection of marketing. Associations between measured environments and diet nonetheless remain modest and inconsistent, reflecting exposure misclassification, residential self-selection and the dominance of cross-sectional designs. The strongest evidence of benefit comes not from informatics alone but from regulatory interventions, such as advertising restrictions, planning controls and fiscal measures, whose evaluation was made possible by commercial purchase data and administrative records. Major unresolved problems include dependence on proprietary corporate data, weak validation of machine-learning classifiers, neglect of informal and digital food retail in low- and middle-income countries, and the risk that smart city partnerships reproduce the commercial influence they are intended to counter. Informatics are therefore best understood as enabling infrastructure for accountability and policy evaluation rather than as interventions in their own right. Public data stewardship, transparent validation standards and quasi-experimental evaluation of platform-level regulation are identified as priorities for research and practice.
Keywords: Commercial determinants of health, digital food environment, geographic information systems, online food delivery, food marketing regulation, urban planning, data governance, health equity