Regulatory Readiness for AI-Enabled Auditing in the United States: A Review of Audit Evidence and Assurance Standards Structure
Enoch Kwabena Twerefour Kissi *
Ernst & Young, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Mary Magdalene Yeboah
Independent Researcher, Texas, USA.
Matthew Oman-Amoako
Independent Researcher, Texas, USA.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Audit evidence is being reshaped by artificial intelligence, both in what it consists of and in how it is produced, from full population testing that replaces sampling with algorithmic coverage to generative systems that draft workpaper narratives and evaluate estimates. This review examines whether existing United States audit evidence and assurance standards are prepared to govern this transition. Using a critical integrative design, the review synthesises Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) and American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) standards, the 2024 rulemaking record on technology-assisted analysis, and academic literature published between 2019 and 2025. Readiness is evaluated across four dimensions drawn from the standards themselves: evidence quality, explainability and documentation, auditor judgment and accountability, and generative AI. None of the four dimensions is fully accommodated. Two are subject to interpretive strain and two are effectively silent, particularly regarding model validation and generative AI, where no standard yet provides specific guidance. These gaps trace to a single underlying condition: technology-neutral standards built for durability that have not been elaborated into guidance specific enough to resolve the judgment calls AI-enabled evidence now presents. The review closes with recommendations addressed to standard setters, including authoritative AI-specific guidance, defined model validation requirements, explainability floors, calibrated accountability standards, and stronger coordination between the PCAOB and the AICPA. The findings speak directly to auditors, regulators, investors, and technology providers navigating a period in which practice has outpaced regulation.
Keywords: Audit evidence, artificial intelligence, assurance standards, PCAOB, regulatory readiness, audit quality