Cost–Benefit Analysis and Regulatory Impact Assessment in Kenya: A Critical Review
Francis Ikapel *
Department of Finance and Accounting, University of Eldoret, Eldoret, Kenya.
Joseph Birundu
Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology, Juja, Kenya.
Leonard Tampushi
National Environment Management Authority (NEMA), Nairobi, Kenya.
Nebat Momanyi
University of Nairobi, Nairobi, Kenya.
Kenneth K’oreje
Water Resource Authority (WRA), Nairobi, Kenya.
Kenneth Esau
Apalis Nature Limited, Voi, Kenya.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) promises to improve the justification, proportionality and accountability of public rules, while cost–benefit analysis (CBA) provides one method of comparing their social consequences. In Kenya, these approaches intersect with statutory obligations for selected subordinate legislation, constitutional public-participation principles, parliamentary scrutiny and sector-specific administrative practice. This critical narrative review examines whether that architecture supports substantive decision quality rather than procedural compliance. Peer-reviewed scholarship on regulatory governance, welfare economics, participation and Kenyan sectoral interventions is synthesised with primary legislation, judicial decisions and accessible regulatory impact statements published before 12 September 2026. The evidence reveals a significant distinction between the legal requirement to produce a regulatory impact statement and demonstrated use of credible counterfactuals, defensible valuation assumptions and alternative options in decisions. Kenyan documents show that analytical practice exists in agriculture, qualifications and environmental regulation, but their publication alone does not establish independently verified quality or realised welfare gains. Research on dairy licensing, professional regulation, public participation and health-sector economic appraisal illustrates both the practical usefulness of quantified evidence and the risks of selection bias, weak causal identification, distributional invisibility and transferring project-level estimates into rule-making. International comparative evidence adds a warning that elaborate templates and formal adoption may coexist with poor analytical integration. The review proposes a proportionate, contestable assessment architecture linking materiality screening, baseline specification, distributional appraisal, meaningful consultation, independent scrutiny and prospective evaluation. Priorities include systematic audits of Kenyan statements, evaluation of the regulatory decision pathway and research on county-level administrative capacity. Kenya's principal challenge is not the absence of an explicit statutory rationale for assessment, but the uncertain connection between published analyses, institutional incentives and verifiable public outcomes.
Keywords: Regulatory governance, subordinate legislation, social welfare appraisal, public participation, compliance costs, regulatory oversight, distributional equity, Kenya