Digital Transformation of Queueing Behaviour in Indonesian Public Services: Technology Adoption, Service Efficiency and Social Order
Dahlia Sarkawi
Universitas Bina Sarana Informatika, Central Jakarta, DKI Jakarta, Indonesia.
Anggi Oktaviani *
Universitas Nusa Mandiri, East Jakarta, DKI Jakarta, Indonesia.
Amin Setio Lestiningsih
Universitas Bina Sarana Informatika, Central Jakarta, DKI Jakarta, Indonesia.
Agus Priadi
Universitas Bina Sarana Informatika, Central Jakarta, DKI Jakarta, Indonesia.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Queue management is a consequential component of public-service delivery because it determines not only how long people wait but also how fairly and predictably they obtain access. Indonesian public institutions have introduced electronic tickets, mobile registration, online appointments and multi-channel systems, yet their implications for actual queueing behaviour remain uncertain. This narrative review examines the intersection of operational performance, technology adoption, institutional governance and social expectations in Indonesian public services. It integrates Indonesia-specific studies of healthcare registration, passport processing and queue-system design with established international research on appointment scheduling, digital government and public value. The literature demonstrates heterogeneous outcomes rather than uniform effectiveness. In three Semarang primary healthcare centres, Widianawati et al. (2021) reported average registration waits of 4.91 minutes for online users and 8.84 minutes for offline users, although only 12% registered online. By contrast, Enggareti et al. (2022) identified ineffective implementation of an online registration initiative at one Semarang health centre because of organisational and infrastructure constraints. These findings illustrate why shorter observed waits, increased satisfaction, digital uptake and compliance with queue rules must be evaluated separately. A three-layer socio-technical framework is developed around technological reliability and accessibility, institutional governance and service capacity, and citizens' understanding, trust and expectations. The framework identifies measurable mechanisms and conditional propositions for future evaluation rather than asserting proven causal relationships. Digital queueing is most plausibly beneficial when accompanied by realistic capacity planning, transparent priority rules, assisted access and end-to-end performance monitoring. The synthesis provides a context-sensitive research agenda for evaluating efficiency, inclusion and procedural fairness without treating the adoption of software as evidence of sustained behavioural transformation.
Keywords: Queue management, digital transformation, Indonesian public services, online registration, procedural fairness, e-government, socio-technical systems